Letter formation order: teaching lowercase letters by stroke family
In short
Teach lowercase letters in groups that share a starting stroke, not in alphabet order. Curved letters like c, a, d, g, o and q go together, as do straight-line letters like l, i, t and j. Grouping makes each new letter easier and keeps b and d apart.
Why not teach letters in alphabet order?
Alphabet order puts unrelated letters side by side. After a, which starts with a curve, comes b, which starts with a straight line, then c, another curve, then d, which looks like b backward. Each new letter needs a different movement, and the two most confused letters, b and d, arrive almost together.
Grouping letters by their first stroke solves both problems. Once a student has learned the curved start for c, the next letters in the family, a, d, g, o and q, reuse that movement. The student learns a family of letters rather than a series of unrelated shapes.
What are the main stroke families?
Different handwriting programs group letters slightly differently, but most use something close to the grouping below. The exact groups matter less than teaching letters that share a movement together.
| Family | Letters | Starting movement | Spoken cue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Curve letters | c, a, d, g, o, q | Start just below the top line and curve back to the left | Start at two, curve around |
| Straight-down letters | l, i, t, j | Start at the top and pull straight down | Top, pull down |
| Down and bump letters | r, n, m, h, b, p | Pull down, then come back up and over | Down, back up, over |
| Slant letters | v, w, x, y, k, z | Start at the top and slant down | Slant down, slant up |
| Other letters | e, s, f, u | Each has its own start | Taught one at a time |
Notice that b sits in the down and bump family and d sits in the curve family. Students form b by pulling down first and d by curving first. Two different starting movements make the letters much harder to confuse.
Which family should come first?
Many teachers start with the curve letters, because c is easy and leads straight into a, d, g, o and q. Six letters from one movement is a quick win, and those letters let students write many short words early on, like "dog", "cod" and "god" combined with a few other letters.
Others start with the straight-down letters, because l, i and t are the simplest strokes. Either choice works. What matters is that students master one family before moving on, and that the order fits your phonics sequence so students can write the words they're learning to read.
How do you teach a stroke family?
Teach the family's starting movement first, then each letter in turn. Use the same spoken cue for every letter in the family, so students connect the words with the movement.
- Introduce the starting movement on a large surface, like a whiteboard, with big arm movements.
- Teach the first letter in the family, saying the cue as you write.
- Have students air-write the letter, then write it on paper several times.
- Add the next letter, pointing out how it starts the same way.
- Mix the family's letters in short words and quick review.
- Teacher
- We know how to make c. Start at two, curve around. Now watch a: start at two, curve around, then up and down.
- Student
- It starts like c!
- Teacher
- Yes. And d starts like c too. Start at two, curve around, then all the way up to the top and down.
- Student
- So d is c with a tall line.
What words should students use while writing?
Short, consistent cues help students remember the movement. Words like "start at the top", "pull down", "curve around" and "back up and over" are easy to say and match the movement. Use the same words every time, and have students say them aloud while writing.
Over time, students stop saying the cues out loud and start using them in their heads. Eventually the movement becomes automatic, and the cues disappear. That's the goal.
When should uppercase letters be taught?
Lowercase letters make up most of what students read and write, so they deserve the most attention. Many teachers teach uppercase letters alongside lowercase in kindergarten for recognition, but focus handwriting practice on lowercase first.
Uppercase letters are mostly straight lines and simple curves, so they're generally easier to form. Teach them as students need them, for names and the start of sentences, and give them more focused practice once lowercase is fluent.
How do you fix a letter formed the wrong way?
Catch it early. Watch students write and note any letter started in the wrong place or formed in the wrong direction. Reteach that letter with the family cue, and have the student write it correctly five times, saying the cue aloud.
For a habit that's already set, short daily practice works better than one long session. Two minutes a day on the problem letter for two weeks usually fixes it, especially if the student also writes it in words.
How does formation link to phonics?
Writing a letter is a chance to practice its sound. Every time a student forms a letter, have them say the sound. When they write words, have them say each sound as they write the matching letter.
Many teachers time handwriting so each letter is formed in the same week it's taught in phonics. The student sees the letter, hears its sound and forms it with their hand, which builds a stronger memory than any one of those alone.
Questions people ask
What order should lowercase letters be taught in?
Should uppercase or lowercase letters be taught first?
Why is b taught separately from d?
Sources
- Santangelo and Graham (2016), A comprehensive meta-analysis of handwriting instruction
- What Works Clearinghouse (2012), Teaching Elementary School Students to Be Effective Writers
- What Works Clearinghouse (2016), Foundational Skills to Support Reading for Understanding in Kindergarten Through 3rd Grade